Increasing Your PPC Quality Score is Like Catching Fruit Flies

By , June 19th, 2013 in PPC | 41 comments
Increasing Your PPC Quality Score is Like Catching Fruit Flies

I still remember the first time I got a 10/10 quality score.

A non-branded keyword that was costing me 25 cents per click on average dropped to 13 cents. My return on investment soared and I sang Google melodies and praises until my neighbors told me to shut up.

It was a nice day.

That was 4 years ago… since then I’ve been able to replicate the process countless of times and getting the same results (almost) every time.

This is what I’ve learned: It’s like catching fruit flies!

Have you ever built a fruit-fly trap? It’s quite easy…

You turn a piece of paper into a cone and put it on top of small jar. That’s your preparation. You put a tasty piece of fruit at the bottom of the jar and you wait. When flies come flying over, they smell the irresistible scent of the fruit and adventure themselves into the cone. Once in the jar, they’re trapped. Can’t come out. Greedy little things.

fruit-fly-trap

Writing an Adwords ad is like preparing your fruit, cutting it into small pieces, squeezing the juices out to liberate the scent. You’re writing about your product, which is the fruit itself, and you want it to attract as many fruit flies as you can.

But here’s the big distinction:

Adwords is like having your fruit fly trap compete against 10 other fruit fly traps.

adwords competition

Pesky competitors.

The world would be easy if it was only you catching flies… but it’s not. The room is full of insects and you’re just one among many advertisers trying to catch them. Only those who’ve built effective fruit flies traps get the highest scores and all the benefits that go with it.

The single most important factor to increasing Quality Score is getting high click-through-rates (CTR). But getting “high” CTR is not enough. It’s about getting higher CTRs than your competition. Very important.

I get lots of emails from folks asking why their Quality Scores are low even as they have high CTR. Well, high CTR compared to what? Sorry sir, your competition has a better fruit fly trap than you do and that’s what Google is telling you with those low scores.

The effectiveness of your ad (in terms of CTR) is evaluated against your competitors and Quality Scores are awarded accordingly. The advertiser with the highest CTR gets a higher score; the lowest CTR gets a lower score. And some aren’t even worth entering the competition.

Now, just like the flytrap is not just a fruit, but also a paper cone and a small container, Quality Score is not just about CTR. But for the sake of brevity, we’ll keep this article to what really matters: the fruit. You can learn about the other Quality Score factors here. (Relevant keywords and relevant landing pages, they only equate to preparing the jar and the cone – anyone can do that).

The single most important element of an effective fruit-fly trap is a fruit that flies REALLY like. That’s your offer.

Then you have to squeeze out the juices so the scent is sprayed around, and sometimes you can add a little vinegar to heighten the scent. That’s your copywriting skills.

It’s the offer and your skills as a copywriter that matters. You need to showcase the right offer and have the skill to write about it effectively in 3 short lines.

1. How to find the right fruit, the right offer.

Know your flies.

Your offer DOES NOT have to be your product. Your offer DOES have to be what searchers want.

I’m not an expert, but I think flies of different kinds like different fruits. An ad can only go as far as the offer it promotes. If the offer isn’t good enough, nobody will care clicking your ad. And your options will be very limited if you stick to just testing one offer.

Again, the offer doesn’t have to be the product you’re selling… unless the product you’re selling is exactly what your prospects want.

Sometimes people want to buy, in which case you’ll need to tell them why they should buy from you. Sometimes people want information, in which case you’ll have to give them that information before asking them to buy.

One of the biggest mistakes we make when writing ads is selling something to people who want information. Or giving information to people who want to buy (although this is rarer).

Most of the times, we have no clue what people want and so we have to research thoroughly the keywords we’re advertising on. Sometimes searchers have no clue what they really want, so we have to do more research to find the offer that will stand out from the competition.

Remember your fruit fly trap is competing against 10 others. If your competition has a tastier fruit, you loose. Winners always get the biggest piece of the pie.

Here’s a nice article for figuring out what people want.

2. Copy that makes the offer… TASTY.

Learn copy writing.

That’s how you squeeze the juices out so flies can’t resist the scent of the right fruit.

I believe copy writing is the single most important skill any advertiser or marketer should have. Mine is always a work in progress.

Certain words are more powerful than others. What you choose your headline to be will have a big impact on how may clicks you attract. How you describe your offer makes a difference on how it is perceived.

There are many ways to write about an offer. Here’s a chart I’ve used myself for quite a while now when I’m out of inspiration:

Learn how to use this chart on Brad’s blog, where I like to hang out.

Adword Quality Score Diagram

Recap:

  1. Click-through-rates have to be higher than the competition.
  2. The offer drives click-through rates.
  3. You need copy-writing skills to portray your offer in its bright light.

Just making sure you’re following…

But if CTR is gauged against my competition, how do I know what I’m competing against? Is there a way to know what my competitors CTRs are?

Glad you asked.

3. Two accurate ways to discover your competition’s CTR

Bing Ads Intelligence

It’s the worst thing I’ve ever had to install on my MacBook. And I’ve never regretted it. If you can summon the patience to go through the trouble of installing it on your computer, you’ll be rewarded with data Google will never deign provide you. I had to partition my hard drive and install Windows so I could use this thing.

It has wealth of competitive information. Like keyword historical performance on Bing. My favorite is the ability to see keyword performance by ad position. Yes, it includes CTRs.

Let me say that again. You can see the CTR of a keyword for each position on the search results. You want to know the average CTR is for an ad in position 1? You can. Position 5? You can.

If Stefanie from Unbounce ventured herself into the wonderful world of PPC, here’s the CTR she would need to beat for position 1 in hopes of getting high Quality Scores:

bing ads intelligence

That’s 1.10% for the term “landing page”.

Three VERY important remarks:

  1. It’s Bing data, but still good enough to be used as a proxy for Adwords.
  2. You need to use the “Keyword Performance” tool, not the “Bid Estimate” as it will give very different data. The keyword performance is the one that shows actual competitive data.
  3. In order to get high QS, you need to have much higher CTR than what you see. It’s not enough to be average. Stefanie would need CTR’s in the range of 2-3% to get high scores for the keyword.

Here are the complete instructions using it:

  1. Create a Bing Ads account if you don’t have one.
  2. Make sure you have Microsoft Excel installed on your computer. If you’re on a mac, it might work from your the Excel version of mac. Try that first. On my mac, I had to install Windows first.
  3. Download Bing Ads Intelligence extension here and install it.
  4. Open Excel and go to the Bing Ads Intelligence tab in top right corner.
  5. Insert a list of keywords in a sheet.
  6. Select that list of keywords and click on the arrow below “Keyword Performance”.
  7. Choose the options you want, like which position you to see data for, the time range, etc.
  8. Click “run” and you’re good to go.

Analyze completion in Adwords

Most people don’t know about this one either.

There is a place in adwords where you can see an evaluation of your performance against your competition. This one doesn’t give you actual numbers like the Bing tool, but it will tell you if you’re doing better or worse.

This may be a great place to start if you don’t have the patience dealing the Bing tool installation.

I have a client who has low Quality Scores for his search keywords. He advertises used cars. Here’s what the Analyze Competition tool shows:

analyse competition

The blue bar represents my client; the yellow/orange bar represents the competition. As you can see, we’re way below average in terms of CTR. That’s exactly why we have bad scores in this market.

Here’s how to get to this little known tool:

analyse competition full
  1. In your Adwords account, click on “Opportunities”.
  2. In the left sidebar, click on “Analyze Competition”.
  3. Choose CTR as the metric you want to compare.
  4. Filter your data by your geographical location.
  5. Find the category that you belong to and see how you’re doing.

That’s pretty much it.

Now go build that amazing pay-per-click fruit-fly trap.

Last note. The fruit-fly trap, what does it look like? A conversion funnel. All those sexy landing pages you’ve been creating with Unbounce… would you like more conversions?

It’s the exact same principle.

– Christian N


About The Author

Photo of Christian N

Christian N. is the Co-founder of Tenscores.com, the first Quality Score tool of its kind. Follow him on twitter (at your risk and peril - you’ve been warned).
» More blog posts by

Comments

  1. Michael Erickson says:

    Great article.
    I’m checking out ten scores right now.

  2. Lisa says:

    Wonderful, informative article! Thanks!!

  3. QS is a challenge… that’s for sure. I like that you showed how to utilize AdWords “Analyze competition” feature – thanks :-)

  4. […] Increasing Your PPC Quality Score is Like Catching Fruit Flies, Unbounce […]

  5. Good article Chris – the examples & explanations are solid!

  6. Good article and discussion too.

  7. Very good article! and easy to read

  8. Andrew says:

    Great article Chris. I am a paid-up Tenscores fan already.

    • Chris says:

      What’s up Andrew! Nice to see a customer here. By the way, we have a shiny new tool coming up in the next few weeks in Tenscores, this one is taking things to a new level. Looking for test-subjects, hit me up if you’re interested: chris at tenscores dot com

  9. Chico says:

    Very nice and funny comparison Chris. Like to see som enew ideas like the Bing check.

    Thank you! Great Post

  10. […] Continue reading here: Increasing Your <b>PPC</b> Quality Score is Like Catching Fruit Flies <b>…&l… […]

  11. […] Increasing Your PPC Quality Score is Like Catching Fruit Flies, Unbounce […]

  12. As a different solution to the same problem: we use a vaccuum cleaner to get rid of fruit flies. I wonder what’s the vaccuum cleaner in AdWords these days (product listing ads, remarketing, …). Great article, thanks.

    P.S. Chris, I would be happy to serve as a test-subject for the new functionality in TenScores :)

    • Chris says:

      Vacuum cleaner… hmm, that would be an unfair advantage against my little fruit fly trap. Ha! Sounds like what Tenscores is, hehe… especially with the automation coming up. I’ll send you the details by email. Thanks!

  13. Matt says:

    Great article Christian.

    I didn’t know about the analyse competition tool in AdWords – thanks for that golden nugget.

    One small issue, you forgot to link to the Bing Ad Intelligence Tool in this sentence.

    “Download Bing Ads Intelligence extension here and install it.”

    You can find it here: http://advertise.bingads.microsoft.com/en-us/bing-ads-intelligence

  14. Cevu says:

    Very good article. I have read with interest. Thank you for useful information and good luck.

  15. Martin says:

    Great article Chris.

    What a pitty Adwords doesn’t alow you to write your own keyword list and see your and the competition performance on it.

  16. This is beautiful! I love all the graphs. :( Unfortunately, I am just having TERRIBLE luck with adwords, I think I may just turn it over to an organization for my online tree nursery

  17. Thank you for sharing with us the information. Very useful and well structured!

  18. Many couples are delaying family planning due to a myriad of reasons. Probably at the top of this list is financial .Today couples recognize that the expense of raising a child to maturity has more than tripled even in their lifetime. As a result, mothers are working well into the last trimester of there pregnancy Job stress along with job uncertainty places many woman at risk for premature births and earlier deliveries. Too often, couples are unable to give notice to other siblings and family members when the “unexpected occurs” Erin’s story (Deans/Dino’s ) early arrival is a story of a four year old who shares her thoughts related to her brothers early arrival. From the beginning we travel with Erin through the maze of thoughts and feelings related to her experiences with this wonderful process viewed through a young child’s eyes.
    This book can not only help those families who have experience premature births but others who might have complications that could limit the necessary time needed for small children that may not be prepared for the unexpected days ahead.

  19. Kory says:

    Great post. I have a very high traffic Google AdWords keyword that generates most of my business (150+ leads a month) for around $3 per lead (6 – 30 cents per click). However, in the “Analyze Competition” section I am beating all competition. Yet I still have a quality score of 3 even though my CTR averages over 10%. Any ideas?

    • Chris says:

      Make sure you’re looking at it in the correct category of analyse competition. That’s important. If it’s still true, then confirm it by checking the Bing Ads tool as I described in the post, that will give you a more accurate competitive CTR. If you still find that you’re way above the competition, then make sure all the other conditions for high QS are met, here are my 5 commandments:

      http://www.tenscores.com/book/the-5-commandments-to-1010-quality-scores/

      I’m very interested in what you find, please email me and I can help you further: chris at tenscores dot com

  20. The one statement you made about selling to people who want information, and selling information who want to buy something is so true. I usually remedy this problem by offering both information, and also giving people to buy something at the same time.

    • Chris says:

      That’s if you have enough space to do both. On a landing page, it might work, in an adwords ad you have to choose one or the other. Thanks Randall.

  21. Vijay says:

    The matter of fact is that, we all looking for revenue from the blog and that’s why we are blogging and searching grate ideas. I like the idea as well as the presentation of that.

  22. allestimento says:

    This is a great post That i expected. Thanks for your post.

  23. Franco says:

    wow Chris + Unbounce, this post ROCKS!

x
Get actionable optimization tips delivered straight to your inbox.

You'll learn:

  • What it takes to build successful marketing campaigns
  • Why your landing page design and copy might be working against you
  • How to increase conversions while delighting leads and customers